CO129-340 - Governor Nathan Acting Governor May - 1907 [4-6] — Page 221

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

217

homest

be no guarantee that the Canton mint would refrain from more Subsidiary coinage, with the result that Hongkong coins being used as a reserve currency by Chinese criminals while the subject is treated as a debased coinage, in which case the Hongkong coinage may disappear (being melted down to make the new coins) but out of the extent of withdrawal it is selling at a bullion value.

£ trade would be disastrous but would be ameliorated by the withdrawal of Hongkong coins. Of course withdrawal suffered than cancelled but a benefit the Revenue by debilitating British currency that benefit would be more by the cost of withdrawal) and not, as it seems & now, benefit the trade of Hongkong which must be conducted largely in the medium of Chinese currency & subject to an equal, & probably a greater, discount in the direction of withdrawal: hence therefore until it is known that the Chinese will take withdrawing this matter, any action by Hongkong British Coins from circulation would be premature, & once misplaced.

What the cost of loss without any corresponding gain were to I have no data for calculation. I may differently estimate it $40,000. I turned have thought it much more. The face value of the subsidiary coins is I understand about the selling value as £360,000 p.a. less than that bullion value of course also upon the weight of the coins in relation to their face value & not merely on the proportion of alloy) & upon the price of silver at the time.

Transport, insurance & Agents' charges have to be added. Say my loss to the Bank "something under $3000 is not worth it was loss very serious matter."

The Alternative is to continue the present system. This costs (say £3600 p.a.) I broadly think & me it advisable to accept it for the drawbacks unless some cooperation from China in any reform can be obtained. Without that I think it is a grave part of the Chinese currency:- "the part of Hongkong would be to sink without a hallmark. 'Hongkong for currency is sure at 97.66. this is key to conical & 11½ %.

6.6.07.

Ar

Edit History

2026-06-04 08:01:56 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
217 homest be no guarantee that the Canton mint would refrain from more Subsidiary coinage, with the result that Hongkong coins being used as a reserve currency by Chinese criminals while the subject is treated as a debased coinage, in which case the Hongkong coinage may disappear (being melted down to make the new coins) but out of the extent of withdrawal it is selling at a bullion value. £ trade would be disastrous but would be ameliorated by the withdrawal of Hongkong coins. Of course withdrawal suffered than cancelled but a benefit the Revenue by debilitating British currency that benefit would be more by the cost of withdrawal) and not, as it seems & now, benefit the trade of Hongkong which must be conducted largely in the medium of Chinese currency & subject to an equal, & probably a greater, discount in the direction of withdrawal: hence therefore until it is known that the Chinese will take withdrawing this matter, any action by Hongkong British Coins from circulation would be premature, & once misplaced. What the cost of loss without any corresponding gain were to I have no data for calculation. I may differently estimate it $40,000. I turned have thought it much more. The face value of the subsidiary coins is I understand about the selling value as £360,000 p.a. less than that bullion value of course also upon the weight of the coins in relation to their face value & not merely on the proportion of alloy) & upon the price of silver at the time. Transport, insurance & Agents' charges have to be added. Say my loss to the Bank "something under $3000 is not worth it was loss very serious matter." The Alternative is to continue the present system. This costs (say £3600 p.a.) I broadly think & me it advisable to accept it for the drawbacks unless some cooperation from China in any reform can be obtained. Without that I think it is a grave part of the Chinese currency:- "the part of Hongkong would be to sink without a hallmark. 'Hongkong for currency is sure at 97.66. this is key to conical & 11½ %. 6.6.07. Ar
Baseline (Original)
} 217 homest be no guarantee that the Cantin mint would refrain from more Subsidiary commiage, with the resuch that Hongkong coins bruce Safety flanced as a feverse currency by Chaincre crimes while the subject Ir I leash as fecal a discount. is there any guaran the Unt Curiase mut issive a debased commage, in which case the Hongkong coniage may disaffean (being mettere down to make the new crins) bett out the Evo the fut to the Exfente of will drawing it a Selling to at hellion Value. £ trade bouede l disastrous but would but I amclioratest by In other words the withdrawal of Hongkong coins F of course withdrawal fufered. than cancelled but a benefit the Recrime by de habilitating British Partsochany Commis that benefit bouche i mare by the cost of with drawal) and not, as it fenus & mo, benefit the trade of thougthong thich must the medium of Chinese currency & brush to per fare inducted langely im I hate to an equal, & deobably a Denter, discorrent. in the directin with chaval : hebrich there fore tal untie it is known that thefs Churia wes take withdrawing this matter, any action by Hongkong British Corns from criculation boucce I fremature, & lonce mivolon What the cost of loss without any arres fonding fain were to I have no data for calculation. Dit may afferently estimates it $40.000 I turned have thought it 7 I much more. The face value of the subsidiary comis is I understernal :t bout the Selling Jalue as Ѣ the silver thing con tarii, p.a. holme A less than that $360.000 p.a. bullion fences of course also upon the weight of the coins in relation to their face Silver at the line ast { & not merely on on the proportin filter of alloy) & upon the price %% Inte hausport, fun avent & C. Apants' charges hon hh added. Say my to the Bank "some thing under $3000 is not den worth was loss very serious matter. " The Alternatin is to antime the present bystan This Cormat. This was (say £3600 p.a.) I broued beam & me t'h advisable to accept it for the drowns untre of achin Olen Soofera him China in any reform can be obturniece. Without that Bera how I think lad away Abechin Suice as elhores is an write grave part of the Chinesi Aufiri:"- the park of Hongkong wrouse to Sin hu hallan unarts. "Hongkong for currency n is sure at 97.66. this is mey to conical & 111⁄2 7%. 6.6.07. Ar
2026-06-04 08:01:56 · Baseline
View content

}

217

homest

be no guarantee that the Cantin mint would refrain from

more Subsidiary commiage, with the resuch that Hongkong coins bruce Safety flanced

as a feverse currency by Chaincre crimes while the subject

Ir I leash as fecal a discount. is there any guaran the Unt Curiase

mut issive

a debased commage,

in which case the Hongkong coniage

may

disaffean (being mettere down to make the new crins) bett out the Evo the fut to the Exfente of will drawing it a Selling to at hellion Value.

£ trade bouede l disastrous but would but I amclioratest by

In other words the withdrawal of Hongkong coins

F of course withdrawal fufered.

than cancelled

but

a benefit the Recrime by de habilitating British Partsochany Commis

that benefit bouche i mare

by the cost of with drawal) and not, as it fenus & mo, benefit the trade of thougthong thich must

the medium of

Chinese currency & brush

to per fare inducted langely

im

I hate to an equal, & deobably a Denter, discorrent.

in the directin

with chaval

: hebrich there fore tal untie it is known that thefs Churia wes take withdrawing this matter, any action by Hongkong British Corns from criculation boucce I fremature, & lonce mivolon

What the cost of loss without any arres fonding fain were to I have no data for calculation. Dit may afferently estimates it

$40.000

I turned have thought it 7 I much more. The face value of the subsidiary comis is I understernal

:t bout the Selling Jalue as Ѣ

the silver thing con tarii,

p.a.

holme

A

less than that

$360.000

p.a.

bullion

fences of course also upon the weight of the coins in relation to their face

Silver at the line

ast { & not merely on

on the proportin

filter of alloy) & upon the price

%%

Inte hausport,

fun avent

&

C. Apants' charges hon

hh added.

Say my

to the Bank "some thing

under $3000

is not

den worth

was loss very serious matter.

"

The Alternatin is to antime the present bystan

This Cormat.

This was (say £3600 p.a.)

I broued beam & me t'h advisable to accept it for the drowns untre

of

achin

Olen

Soofera him China in any reform can be obturniece. Without that Bera how I think lad

away Abechin Suice as elhores is an write grave part of the Chinesi Aufiri:"-

the park of Hongkong wrouse to Sin hu hallan unarts. "Hongkong for currency

n is sure at 97.66. this is

mey to conical & 111⁄2 7%.

6.6.07.

Ar

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.